Tracklist

Catalogue updated on Oct 11, 2026

1. 1
   Now: I've Been Looking for Someone

   Sam Underwood
   0:24
   
2. 2
   1901: Hello Again

   Sam Underwood
   5:22
   
3. 3
   1944: I Gotta Little Time / We Kiss

   Nolan Gerard Funk
   6:57
   
4. 4
   1967: In Some Other Life

   Jenna Ushkowitz
   3:34
   
5. 5
   1929: Story of My Life

   Al Calderon
   5:01
   
6. 6
   1956: The Greatest of Adventures / Tom

   Rumer Willis
   7:27
   
7. 7
   1912: Ship of Dreams / Listen to the Music

   T.R. Knight
   9:07
   
8. 8
   1976: Opening Montage / Safe / The One I Love

   Cheyenne Jackson
   9:29
   
10. 9
    2002: Performance of a Lifetime / Beyond the Moon

    Cheyenne Jackson
    5:48
    
11. 10
    1989: A Lie / Mistress of the Senator

    Audra McDonald
    7:06
    
12. 11
    Now: The Bed Was Not My Own / Hello Again (Reprise)

    Full cast of Hello Again
    6:40
    
13. 12
    Beyond the Moon (Single) (Bonus Track)

    Audra McDonald
    4:35