Peter Gallagher
Himself / Sky Masterson
Nathan Lane
Himself / Nathan Detroit
Jossie DeGuzman
Herself / Sarah Brown
Faith Prince
Herself / Miss Adelaide
Walter Bobbie
Himself / Nicely-Nicely Johnson
?
John Carpenter
Himself / Arvide Abernathy
Steve Ryan
Himself / Lt. Brannigan
Ernie Sabella
Himself / Harry the Horse
J.K. Simmons
Himself / Benny Southstreet
Herschel Sparber
Himself / Big Jule